The Pilling Report: A Detailed Analysis, Christina Beardsley, for Changing Attitude (England)
The Report of the House of Bishops Working Group on Human Sexuality, chaired by Joseph Pilling, was published on 28 November 2013. (Report [PDF]).
This paper analyses and critiques each section of the Report in detail.
Please note that this material is offered for discussion and comment. It does not represent the current policy or the current attitude of the Coalition, or any of its constituent groups.
Comments by some Coalition member groups on the report from the House of Bishops’ working group on human sexuality (the Pilling Report)
Individual member groups have issued their own press statements and comments on the Pilling Report:
Accepting Evangelicals [PDF].
Changing Attitude [Blog].
Inclusive Church [Blog].
The Church of England report of the House of Bishops Working Group on Human Sexuality, or the Pilling Report, was commissioned by the House of Bishops of the Church of England in January 2012, and was published on the 28 November 2013. The issues of providing liturgies for the celebration or blessing of same-sex marriages and civil partnerships were discussed, and the following arguments were made:
For immediate use: press release in response to the report from the House of Bishops’ working group on human sexuality (the Pilling Report)
The Coalition welcomes the publication of the Pilling Report and we appreciate that it was made public so soon.
It is good that the report recognises the diversity of theological views on this issue, including within the Evangelical wing of the Church. We are glad that the report denounces homophobia (though it is not clearly enough defined). We believe that it makes it easier for clergy to bless partnerships publicly and it calls for further discussion to try to discern where the Spirit is leading the church.
It is also good that LGB&T clergy will not face intrusive questioning though they are still asked to promise to abide by a code which would exclude most from the kind of loving and supportive relationship which others can enjoy.
We are disappointed that the Report has only mentioned rather than included transgender people in the discussion, despite submissions from transgender and LGB&T Christian organisations.
We are also disappointed that no liturgy of thanksgiving or blessing is proposed, but overall we are thankful for the working party’s effort. We trust and hope that the report may move the Church of England forward.
The Coalition and its member organisations stand ready to support the proposed facilitated conversations both in dioceses and nationally. We look forward to being fully included in all steps to help the Church of England find a way forward and we value the Pilling report as a useful contribution to the coming debate
We are also convinced that there must be a greater openness to, and a wider understanding, of the extensive range of scientific and theological work that has been, and is currently being undertaken on transgender issues and same-sex issues in addition to those relied upon within the report. We believe that what is presented there is insufficient to provide a strong and reliable foundation for the proposed conversations and we trust that these issues will be further addressed in the coming debate.
Press Release [PDF].
In December 2013, the House of Bishops will receive a report into the Church of England’s “Approach to Human Sexuality” from a group chaired by Joseph Pilling. It is understood that the report will then be discussed by the full College of Bishops in January 2014.
When the House of Bishops established the review in July 2011 it did so because it wished “To offer proposals on how the continuing discussion within the Church of England about these matters might best be shaped in the light of the listening process. Our intention is to produce a further consultation document”. The Pilling report will therefore be a report to the House of Bishops and it will then be for the House to decide, in the light of the report, what proposals and process of consultation it wishes to launch.
The LGB&T Anglican Coalition expresses its appreciation of the discussions it has already had with the Archbishop of Canterbury, and it is now understood that the outcome of these talks will be subsumed into the Pilling Report. There are already leaks about what the Pilling report may contain. See for example:
http://www.thinkinganglicans.org.uk/archives/006294.html and clearly a period of intense discussion lies ahead. It is important that all those who wish to contribute to these matters participate in the debate.